Blog Layout

Portugal – US nationals and the Portuguese non-habitual tax resident (NHR) regime

13 May 2022
Sérgio Varela Alves

Capital gains from the alienation of movable property (personal property) in the United States of America: their exemption from taxation in Portugal under the non-habitual resident regime

Under the non-habitual resident regime, capital gains from the alienation of movable property (personal property) - e.g., from selling stocks or other participations in companies or other legal entities -, are in general taxed in Portugal at a flat tax rate of 28% in personal income tax, except if the capital gains are earned by a company or other legal entity located abroad owned by the non-habitual resident individual in Portugal, or if the income arises from a permanent establishment he or she also owns abroad, e.g., like an office. 


Article 81.º, no. 5, § a) of the Portuguese Personal Income Tax Code clearly states that to «non-habitual residents in Portuguese territory who obtain, abroad, income of category […] G [capital gains], the exemption method applies, provided that [income] may be taxed in the other Contracting State, in accordance with the double tax convention concluded by Portugal with that State».


Therefore, Portugal will tax the capital gains from the alienation of movable property, except if they may be taxed abroad under the double tax convention, and even if the other State doesn’t effectively exercise its power.


At a first glimpse, the double tax convention Portugal signed with the United States of America predicts a similar solution in its article 14.º, where on its point 6 we find a default rule asserting that «gains from the alienation of any property other than property referred to in paragraphs 1 through 5 shall be taxed only in the Contracting State where the alienator is a resident».


Nonetheless, it happens that article 1.º, § b) of the Protocol to the double tax agreement adds that «notwithstanding any provision of the Convention […] a Contracting State may tax its residents, and the United States may tax its citizens, as if the Convention had not come into effect. For this purpose, the term citizen shall include a former citizen whose loss of citizenship had as one of its principal purposes the avoidance of tax, but only for a period of 10 years following such loss».


This apparent contradiction was subject to an arbitral decision from the arbitration court in Lisbon “CAAD” because the Portuguese Tax Authorities wanted to tax the income, but the taxable person argued that the Protocol should be instead applied, meaning that the exemption predicted on article 81.º, no. 5, § a) of the Portuguese Personal Income Tax Code had its determination complied with.


Thus, in the words of the court, “in relation to income of category G (capital gains) from a North American source, the subsumption to § a), nº. 5 of Article 81.º of the Portuguese Personal Income Tax Code appears to be linear, since such income is, in accordance with the Convention, of which the aforementioned Protocol forms an integral part, taxable in the State of residence (Portugal) and, at the same time, in the State of nationality (United States of America)», meaning the exemption method should have been applied.


The decision may still be appealed, and there is no formal precedent deriving from it, which means that the Portuguese Tax Authority is not legally bound by it in similar future situations. Nevertheless, the Court ruling was unanimous, and it represents a first judicial case to prevent the taxation of any type of non-Portuguese sourced capital income or gains at the level of US nationals residing in Portugal and benefitting from the NHR regime.

Sérgio Varela Alves

Tax Consultant

Portugal has implemented a series of tax benefits to encourage urban rehabilitation.
by Diogo Pedro and Cleuzina Cruz 1 April 2025
To maximise these benefits, property buyers should assess eligibility before purchasing a property, ensuring it meets the criteria for IMT exemption.
The most important requirement is demonstrating an effective connection to the Portuguese community
by Florbela Lopes 31 March 2025
Acquiring Portuguese citizenship through marriage or a civil partnership with a Portuguese national may appear to be a straightforward legal process.
The present overview provides a comprehensive and structured analysis of the D2 Visa.
by Luís Maria Branco and Tomás Melo Ribeiro 28 March 2025
The D2 Visa allows non-EU, EEA, and Swiss nationals to legally start a business, invest, or engage in entrepreneurial activities in Portugal.
AIMA may suspend the 'green lane' if there are security concerns or significant difficulties.
26 March 2025
A “green lane” will be established to streamline the work visa process for foreign nationals being recruited by Portuguese companies.
Here are some insights and practical recommendations to help you through the 2024 tax season.
by António Pratas Nunes 25 March 2025
The income earned in 2024 must be declared between 1 April and 30 June 2025 by submitting the IRS Model 3 declaration.
Outro benefício desse estatuto é o direito a solicitar um Cartão de Cidadão.
by Danielle Avidago 14 March 2025
Na área migratória, a isenção de visto não só para turismo, mas também para atividades culturais, empresariais ou jornalísticas.
Portugal is a growing hotspot for entrepreneurs and businesses aiming to expand into Europe.
by Tomás Melo Ribeiro 6 March 2025
Favourable Corporate Tax Rate: Portugal offers a corporate income tax rate of 20%, which is among the most competitive in the EU.
An injunction helps creditors claim outstanding debts quickly through a legal mechanism.
by Margarida Tempera 27 February 2025
Engaging a lawyer is crucial; your defense's success relies on valid proof, procedural adherence, and meeting deadlines.
Portugal's traditions, charm, and cuisine are so integral that legal citizenship feels only fair.
by Danielle Avidago 26 February 2025
Portuguese citizenship, for some, means reconnecting to their parent or grandparent who spent their entire childhood amazing them with stories of a country.
Electric car owners benefit from no oil changes, fewer wearing parts, and lower maintenance costs.
by Cleuzina Cruz 25 February 2025
Electric cars have garnered significant attention compared to conventional vehicles, owing to their environmental and economic advantages.
More posts
Share by: